top of page

Are You Buying the Item, or the Discount?How a sale gives us permission to buy.

Nov 7
4 min read

Updated: Nov 13

Anchoring in sales pitch.
Anchoring makes spending feel smart.

You went in to buy a pair of socks. On the way to the counter, you spotted a jacket. You tried it on. It looked good. Then you saw the tag.


Was $200. Now $80.


You hadn’t planned on buying a jacket. Now you’re wondering whether you’d be silly to leave it there. By the time you get home, you’ve already worked out what you’ll say if someone asks about it. “It was $200.”


Funny how the first thing you tell them is the price you never paid.


The number that gets there first

The $200 on the tag is what psychologists call an anchor. It gives you a starting point for deciding what the jacket is worth. With $200 in your head, $80 feels cheap. If you’d seen the same jacket on the same rack with a plain $80 tag, you might have tried it on, liked it and put it back.


Working out value takes effort. You could compare the fabric, stitching, fit and price with other jackets. The old price offers a much quicker way to judge. Someone has already put a value on it, and you’re being offered it for considerably less. Of course, the tag tells you very little about whether the jacket is worth $80 to you. You still have to decide how much you like it, whether you’ll wear it and what you’re comfortable spending. But once you’ve seen $200, it can be difficult to give $80 a fair hearing on its own.


You can see the same thing at a house inspection. A place goes on the market for $1.2 million. A few weeks later, the agent calls to say the owners will consider $1.1 million. Suddenly, a figure you might have thought was steep feels like an opportunity. The house is exactly as you saw it last Saturday. What’s changed is the number you’re comparing it with. Whether $1.1 million represents good value still depends on the property and what comparable homes are selling for. Yet the asking price has already helped shape how you feel about it.


When a discount gives you permission

Sometimes you want the jacket the moment you put it on. You like the way it sits across the shoulders. You picture wearing it to dinner on Friday. Then you remember the two jackets hanging at home and start to put it back. That’s when the old price earns its place on the tag. For a moment, buying a third jacket feels like the financially sensible thing to do. You’ve spotted a good deal. You’re being smart about money.


The discount gives you an answer to the small voice asking whether you really need another one. “At that price, I couldn’t leave it there.”


It’s a familiar explanation because it lets us feel comfortable with a decision we were already tempted to make. We can enjoy the purchase and congratulate ourselves on being careful with money. Retailers can reinforce that feeling at every step. The crossed-out price gives you something to compare. The red 60% OFF makes the difference hard to miss. The email saying the sale ends at midnight adds urgency. By checkout, the store is congratulating you on how much you’ve saved.


Sometimes that’s exactly the reassurance you were looking for. It’s been a long week and you fancy buying yourself something. You open a sale email while you’re waiting for the kettle to boil and ten minutes later you have three things in your cart. Somewhere in those ten minutes, I feel like buying something turned into I’d be wasting money if I passed this up.


One purchase may barely register. But when every sale supplies a fresh reason to shop, the spending can accumulate while each purchase still feels justified.


Give the $80 a moment of its own

If you’d been looking for a jacket and expected to pay $200, finding one you like for $80 is a good result. If you went in for socks, you’re walking out with a jacket and $80 less than you had when you walked in. You might be perfectly happy with that exchange. It’s worth hearing it put that way before you pay.


If the tag simply said $80, would I still buy it?


Maybe you would. It fits well, you’ll wear it often, and you’re happy to spend the money. Or maybe the thought of getting a $200 jacket for $80 was the best part. That feeling can wear off before you’ve even taken the tags off. If you’re still tossing it up, leave it on the rack while you go and find the socks. If you’re shopping online, close the tab and finish making that cup of tea. See whether you’re still thinking about the jacket once you’ve had a moment away from the sale.


You may go back and buy it. You may find you’ve already stopped thinking about it. Either way, you’ve given yourself a chance to decide how much you want the jacket without the old price doing quite so much of the talking.


Ready to change the way you think about money?


Sound financial strategies matter. But lasting change happens when you understand the behaviours, beliefs and habits driving your decisions. For less than the cost of a takeaway dinner, Where Did All the Money Go?  offers practical insights into the psychology of money and the behaviours that shape your financial outcomes.

Image Jaeneen Cunningham


Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page